Different Types of Business Closures and the Status of Employees
A business that ceases operations can do so in various ways. And that makes quite a difference, not only for the employees who lose their jobs as a result, but also for the company and its directors. For example, are employees entitled to a transition payment? Is there a notice period? And when can they claim unemployment benefits? In this blog, we compare the three forms of business closure.
Bankruptcy
In the event of bankruptcy, the court appoints a trustee, who manages and liquidates the estate under the supervision of a bankruptcy judge. The trustee must take all interests into account, including those of the employees. The trustee may terminate the employment contract pursuant to Article 40 of the Bankruptcy Act. This, with the authorization of the bankruptcy judge. The employment contract terminates subject to the notice period, which may not exceed six weeks.
The greatest disadvantage for the employee is that there is no entitlement to a transition allowance. It is also common for the employer to be unable to continue paying wages. In that case, the UWV takes over wage payments through the wage guarantee scheme (Article 61 et seq. of the Unemployment Act). The UWV will then reimburse the back wages for up to thirteen weeks prior to the termination, the wages for the notice period of up to six weeks, and any outstanding vacation pay and pension contributions for up to the preceding year. After the notice period, an employee – provided all conditions are met – is entitled to unemployment benefits.
Accelerated Liquidation
If a legal entity no longer generates income, it may be dissolved through an accelerated liquidation. This is possible even if there are outstanding debts. Since the enactment of the Temporary Act on Transparency in Accelerated Liquidation, the board must submit a financial report to the Chamber of Commerce within fourteen days and inform creditors, including employees, of this.
For employees, this is by far the most unfavorable scenario. There is no formal notice of termination: the legal entity ceases to exist immediately by operation of law, and with that, the employment contract also ends, without there being any legal grounds for dismissal. This means no notice period, no transition payment, and no continued payment of wages during a notice period. For back wages accrued prior to the date of dissolution, employees may still be eligible for the wage guarantee scheme; however, as of the date of dissolution, the employee is immediately reliant on regular unemployment benefits. In the worst-case scenario, an employee may not qualify for these benefits. For example, if the employee does not (yet) meet the eligibility requirements.
Business Closure with Liquidation
If a company decides to voluntarily cease operations and there are still assets remaining, a liquidator is appointed to wind up the legal entity. If the debts exceed the assets, the liquidator must file for bankruptcy.
To terminate employees, the employer must first submit a termination request to the UWV due to complete business closure. The UWV will verify whether operations are actually being discontinued and not, for example, continued under a different legal entity. Only after receiving approval may the employer give notice, in accordance with the applicable notice period.
This is the most favorable scenario for employees. The employer is obligated to pay the transition allowance, in addition to wages during the notice period. After the notice period ends, the employee is eligible for unemployment benefits.
In Conclusion
The manner in which a business is terminated largely determines how employees are affected financially. In the case of a standard business termination with liquidation, the employee is best protected. In the case of a “turbo liquidation”, the employee is in the worst position.
Do you have questions about which type of business termination is most appropriate or about the position of employees in that context? Please feel free to contact us.