icon

How a Hyrox led to immediate termination

An employee called in sick due to stress at work. Shortly afterward, she informed her employer that she had mononucleosis, that even minor physical exertion left her exhausted, and that she was sleeping a lot during the day. Two weeks later, she participated in a Hyrox: a fitness competition in which participants run eight one-kilometer laps, interspersed with strenuous fitness exercises. The employer discovers this and summarily dismisses her. Is this summary dismissal justified? The subdistrict court in Tilburg ruled that the summary dismissal was justified (ECLI:NL:RBZWB:2026:8540).

The facts

The employee began working on January 1, 2025. She worked as an internal sales representative at a real estate agency, working 28 hours per week. Things did not go smoothly even in the first year: she regularly called in sick, arrived late, left early, and wanted to adjust her hours. The employer accommodated her on several occasions. Ultimately, the contract was extended for a second year, but now for 24 hours per week. The parties agreed that mutual trust must be restored.

On February 10, 2026, the employee calls in sick, citing, in her own words, tensions in the working relationship. On March 13, 2026, she sends a WhatsApp message to her supervisor stating that she has mononucleosis and a severe throat infection. She explains that even minor exertion leaves her tired and that she sleeps a lot during the day.

Two weeks later, on March 27, 2026, she participates in a Hyrox event. The employer discovers this and confronts her about it. Her response: exercising is healthy. On April 3, 2026, she is summarily dismissed.

The Subdistrict Court’s ruling

The employee accepts the termination but challenges its legality. She requests fair compensation, compensation for wrongful termination, and a transition payment.

The labor court judge does not agree with the employee’s defense and reasons as follows: The dismissal is not based on the sick leave notification itself, nor on the question of whether she was actually capable of running a Hyrox race. This case revolves around the breach of trust. The parties had discussed restoring trust on multiple occasions. The employee had informed her employer that she had mononucleosis and became tired even from minor exertion. Two weeks later, it turned out that she had participated in a strenuous fitness competition. When the employer confronted her about this, her only explanation was that exercise is healthy.

The subdistrict court judge ruled that, in light of this – given the prior history and the employer’s repeated willingness to accommodate the employee – the employer was justified in losing all confidence in their continued working relationship.

The summary dismissal is legally valid. Consequently, the claim for equitable compensation is denied. The termination was based on urgent cause, and therefore equitable compensation under Article 7:681 of the Dutch Civil Code does not apply.

A transition allowance is granted

Despite the justified summary dismissal, the subdistrict court did award the employee a transition allowance. The law stipulates that a transition allowance is not due if the termination of the employment contract results from serious culpable conduct on the part of the employee (Article 7:673(7)(c) of the Dutch Civil Code). However, an urgent reason does not automatically constitute serious culpability. For that to be the case, there must be exceptional circumstances, and it should not be readily assumed that no transition allowance is due. The subdistrict court judge considers the employee’s conduct to be culpable, but not seriously culpable. The transition allowance is therefore awarded.

Fixed compensation

The employer, in turn, filed a request for payment of fixed compensation pursuant to Article 7:677(2) of the Dutch Civil Code. In the case of a fixed-term employment contract without an early termination clause, this compensation is equal to the wages for the remaining term of the contract.

The subdistrict court grants the claim but reduces the amount from €18,804.60 to €2,106.00 gross (one month’s salary including vacation pay). The reason for this is that the compensation is intended to offset a loss, and the employer has not substantiated what loss it actually suffered.

In conclusion

As a general rule, it is up to the company physician to assess what a sick employee can and cannot do. The subdistrict court therefore did not base the termination on whether the employee was medically fit to participate in a Hyrox event. The issue revolved around the breach of trust: the employee herself reported that she had mononucleosis and became tired even from minor exertions, yet two weeks later she participated in a Hyrox event. When the employer confronted her about this, she responded only by remarking that exercise is healthy. In an employment relationship where the parties had already discussed restoring trust on multiple occasions, that response was insufficient.

Do you have questions about summary dismissal or another employment law issue? Please feel free to contact us.

Any questions?

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
How a Hyrox led to immediate termination
Praktijkgebieden blogs
Auteurfilter blog